Skip to main content

a defense of the new york giants

With Saquon Barkley running wild in the City of Brotherly Love, and the Giants sitting at the bottom of the league's standings, the G-Men have been getting a ton of flack on social media and from talking heads on TV. And yes when the star of your team goes to the division rival for nothing in return that's not exactly a good thing, but even with that said the bashing of the New York Giants has become too much. 

GM Joe Schoen's decision has been criticized time and time again for this mistake, which was highlighted in HBO's Offseason Hard Knocks. The special took viewers inside the life of an NFL GM displaying how teams make free agent signings and draft picks in the offseason. In one of the show's viral moments, Schoen calls Barkley to get him to sign back with NY. An unenthused Barkley was cordial but had his mind set elsewhere. The now infamous clip pans to Giant's owner John Mara who says "I'll Have a Tough Time Sleeping if Saquon Goes to Philadelphia."

John Mara reacts to Saquon Free Agency Decision (via HBO)

In light of this constant criticism, I feel the media has been too harsh on the Giants. In the offseason when Big Blue let Saquon walk, they knew that offering him any more than they already have would set their team back even further than the Daniel Jones contract. After a rough season, I believe Joe Schoen knew that the franchise was in no position to pay for a running back because that comes as a luxury. And as much as I hate to say it, the Eagles are a good team who can afford that luxury.

Philly has a better o-line, QB, and wide receiver group giving Saquon the best chance to play to the best of his ability. That's why he's jumping over people backward and has a chance to win MVP this year. If 26 was still wearing blue, the Giants would still be a sub-.500 team.

Speaking of sub-.500 teams, the Las Vegas Raiders, and Tennessee Titans both lost their Pro Bowl running backs last offseason, yet you rarely hear that being brought up at all. Behind Barkley, former Titan Derrick Henry and former Raider Josh Jacobs are 2 and 3 in rush yards this season, after their original team was forced to let them go for money reasons, just like the Giants.

But unlike the Giants, the Titans and Raiders did a poor job replacing their star RB. Vegas has had a carousel of backs this season none of which have thrived in the role. As for the Tennessee, they overpaid for Tony Pollard who's averaging just 4.3 yards per carry. While Joe Schoen did a nice job replacing Barkley with free agent Devin Singletary as well as drafting up-and-coming rookie RB Tyrone Tracy who broke out for multiple 100-yard games already this season.

While the decision to keep DJ and let Barkley go was not a good one in hindsight, we don't have to bring it up every week, no need to kick us while we're down. 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

NFL MOCK DRAFT 2026

DOM'S NFL MOCK DRAFT 2026 This 2026 Draft has all the makings of a memorable one. According to multiple sources, this could be one of the most trade-heavy draft days in recent memory. Even in an already unpredictable draft, projecting trades is borderline impossible, so I’ll mostly stick to the current order, mixing in a few where it makes sense.  Let's get into it. 1. Las Vegas Raiders: Fernando Mendoza- QB, Indiana It’s become a trend in my recent mock drafts that the No. 1 overall pick feels like a consensus no-brainer, and that continues here. All signs point to Mendoza as the choice. He’s an elite pocket passer and will have the benefit of learning behind recently acquired Kirk Cousins. The real question isn’t who they choose but how long it takes before Mendoza takes over as the starter. 2. New York Jets: David Bailey- Edge, Texas Tech  Last Wednesday, the Jets canceled their top-30 meeting with Bailey, leaving people confused and leading some to believe New York could b...
Post a Comment
Read more

NFL SEASON PREDICTIONS 2025-26

 It's that time of year again, the NFL is officially back with the 2025 season kicking off in less than ten days in Philadelphia. With that, my final regular-season and playoff predictions are set. Think I nailed it? Think I’m out of my mind? Let me know on X and Instagram @domwithablog. Time to break it down. * Indicates a playoff team AFC NORTH Ravens 13-4* Steelers 10-7* Bengals 9-8 Browns 5-12 AFC SOUTH Jaguars 9-8* Texans 8-9 Colts  5-12 Titans 4-13 AFC EAST Bills 12-5* Dolphins 10-7 Patriots 7-10 Jets 6-11 AFC WEST Chiefs  12-5* Chargers 11-6* Broncos 10-7* Raiders  5-12 NFC NORTH Lions 11-6* Packers 10-7* Bears 10-7* Vikings 7-10 NFC SOUTH Buccaneers 11-6* Panthers 9-8* Falcons 7-10 Saints 3-14 NFC EAST Eagles 12-5* Commanders 9-8 Cowboys 7-10 Giants 5-12 NFC WEST  Rams 12-5* 49ers 9-8 Cardinals 7-10 Seahawks 5-12 PLAYOFFS DOM WITH A BLOG OFFICIAL PRESEASON SUPER BOWL PREDICTION RAVENS DEF. RAMS
Post a Comment
Read more

Houston is a Problem

In a wild NBA weekend, the Oklahoma City Thunder won the franchise's first-ever championship, Tyrese Haliburton tore his Achilles, and Kevin Durant was traded to the Rockets. As crazy as it sounds, the Durant news felt more important to me as an NBA fan than Game 7. The Thunder felt like a team of destiny all playoffs long, and after Haliburton went down, it all but solidified they’d become champs. But this article is focused on the next chapter of KD's career in H-Town. Yesterday afternoon, while on stage at Fanatics Fest in New York, Kevin Durant found out he had been traded to the Houston Rockets in exchange for the No. 10 pick in the 2025 draft, five second-round picks, Jalen Green, and NBA “villain” Dillon Brooks. (image via theringer.com) This marks the end of the big three of Booker, Beal, and Durant in Phoenix—yet another failed superteam on KD’s résumé. But this move to Houston feels different. Durant, who admitted Houston was at the top of his preferred destination li...
Post a Comment
Read more